How to Tell If an Egg Is Fertile: The Bullseye and Candling

By Peter Chan

Researched with AI help and checked against the sources listed below.

You can tell if an egg is fertile in two ways: crack it open and look for a "bullseye" on the yolk, or candle it after a few days in an incubator and look for a small red spot with blood vessels. An infertile egg has a small, plain white spot on the yolk; a fertile egg has a slightly larger spot with a tiny clear centre, which looks like a ring.

Quick answer

  • Cracked egg: plain small white spot = infertile; slightly larger spot with a clear centre (a "bullseye") = fertile.
  • Candling: after about 4 to 7 days of incubation, a fertile egg shows a reddish spot with blood vessels; an infertile egg looks clear apart from the yolk shadow.
  • No rooster, no fertile eggs. Hens lay without a rooster.
  • A blood spot does not mean an egg is fertile.
  • Illinois Extension says there is no scientific evidence that fertile eggs are nutritionally superior.
How to tell if an egg is fertile: infertile spot vs fertile bullseye on the yolk

Do Hens Need a Rooster to Lay Eggs?

No. University of Florida IFAS Extension calls it a popular misconception that a rooster must be present for hens to lay, and says a rooster is only needed if fertile eggs are desired. So if you have no rooster, every egg is infertile and the question is settled. If you do keep a rooster with your hens, some or all of the eggs may be fertile, and the methods below will help you tell. Our guide Do you need a rooster for eggs? covers the rest of that question.

Method 1: Crack the Egg and Look for the Bullseye

Every egg yolk has a small white spot on its surface. In an infertile egg this is called the blastodisc; in a fertile egg it is called the blastoderm. University of Kentucky poultry specialist Jacquie Jacob explains the difference simply: when broken open, the infertile egg has a small white spot on the surface of the yolk, while in a fertile egg the spot is slightly larger and has a minute clear spot in the middle.

That clear centre surrounded by a white ring is why people call it a bullseye. To see it:

  1. Crack the egg gently into a clear bowl or onto a plate so the yolk stays whole.
  2. Let the yolk settle and turn the plate slowly under good light until you find the white spot.
  3. Look at its shape: a small, plain, solid-looking spot suggests infertile; a slightly bigger spot that looks like a ring with a clear middle suggests fertile.

This is the only way to check an egg you plan to eat, but it works best with practice and fresh eggs, and once an egg is cracked it cannot be hatched.

Fertile vs Infertile: What You See

We put the signs from four extension sources side by side.

CheckInfertile eggFertile eggSource
Cracked egg: white spot on the yolkSmall white spot (blastodisc)Slightly larger spot with a tiny clear centre (blastoderm, the "bullseye")Univ. of Kentucky (Jacob)
Candling after 4 to 7 days of incubationClear except for a slight shadow cast by the yolkSmall reddish area with blood vessels; "spider-like"Mississippi State; Illinois
Candling: embryo died early(not applicable)Blood ring around the embryoMississippi State; Illinois
Blood spot when crackedCan appearCan appearOklahoma State: not a sign of fertility
After the rooster is removed(no rooster ever)Eggs may stay fertile for up to 4 weeksMississippi State

Sources: University of Kentucky (Jacob) on extension.org; Mississippi State University Extension; University of Illinois Extension; Oklahoma State University Extension.

Method 2: Candling During Incubation

If you want to hatch eggs, you cannot crack them, so you candle them instead: shine a bright light through the shell in a dark room and look at the shadow inside. Illinois Extension says white eggs can be tested for fertility on the third day of incubation, but brown-shelled eggs on the fifth or sixth day, because it is difficult to see the embryo clearly before that. Mississippi State University Extension says eggs are normally tested after 4 to 7 days of incubation.

  • Fertile and growing: Illinois Extension describes a small reddish area with blood vessels extending away from it, and Mississippi State says a live embryo is "spider-like" in appearance.
  • Infertile: Mississippi State says an infertile egg appears clear except for a slight shadow cast by the yolk.
  • Started but died early: both sources describe a blood ring. Illinois explains that if the embryo dies, the blood draws away from it and forms a ring.

Our step-by-step guide How to candle chicken eggs shows what to expect day by day, and How to incubate chicken eggs covers temperature and humidity.

How Long Do Eggs Stay Fertile After a Rooster Leaves?

Hens store sperm, so fertility does not stop the day a rooster goes. Mississippi State University Extension says that after the rooster is removed, hens will continue to produce fertile eggs for up to four weeks, depending on the species. The same source says that when you change roosters, it may take 3 weeks before you can be sure that all eggs will produce chicks sired by the new rooster.

In practice this means that if you have just removed a rooster, eggs from the next few weeks may still show a bullseye.

Storing Eggs You Want to Hatch

If you plan to hatch fertile eggs, how you store them before the incubator matters. Illinois Extension recommends storing them between 55 and 60°F (about 13 to 16°C) and for no more than seven days. University of Kentucky's Jacob notes that household refrigerators are typically too cold and that storing hatching eggs in the fridge may result in a poor hatch. Eggs for eating, on the other hand, belong in the fridge as usual.

Are Fertile Eggs Different to Eat?

Not in any way that has been shown. Illinois Extension says there is no scientific evidence that fertile eggs are nutritionally superior to infertile ones, and Oklahoma State University Extension puts it simply: an egg is an egg regardless of the colour or whether it is fertile. Jacob explains that after laying, the tiny embryo goes into a kind of pause: it does not die, but it does not develop either, unless the egg is warmed. Collecting eggs promptly and refrigerating them keeps it that way.

Do not confuse a blood spot with fertility. Oklahoma State says the presence of a blood spot does not mean the egg is fertile or that an embryo is forming, and UF/IFAS recommends simply removing blood spots and cooking the egg as normal. Our article on blood spots and meat spots explains what causes them.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you tell if an egg is fertile without cracking it?

Only by candling, and only after the egg has been incubated for a few days. A fresh, unincubated fertile egg looks the same as an infertile one through the shell.

Are the eggs from the shop fertile?

We did not find an official figure for this. Since hens lay without a rooster, an egg can only be fertile if roosters run with the hens, so if you want to know about a particular farm's eggs, ask the farmer.

Will a fertile egg develop in the fridge?

No. Development needs warmth over time, which is why eggs for hatching are kept cool and then incubated. Eggs collected promptly and refrigerated stay as they are.

What does a blood ring mean when candling?

Illinois and Mississippi State Extension both describe a blood ring as a sign that the embryo started to develop and then died. Remove those eggs from the incubator.

Do fertile eggs taste different?

We found no reputable source showing a difference in taste, and the extension sources above found no nutritional difference either.

The Bottom Line

Without a rooster, eggs are not fertile. With one, crack an egg and look for a bullseye, or candle incubated eggs after a few days and look for a red spot with veins. Fertile eggs are eaten like any other egg, and a blood spot is not a sign of fertility.

Have you ever spotted the bullseye on a yolk, or do you keep a flock without a rooster? Tell us in the comments.

Like this guide? Follow CluckSmart on Pinterest for more simple, sourced chicken care guides and checklists.

Sources / Further reading

CluckSmart is an educational resource, not veterinary advice. If a bird is ill or injured, contact a licensed vet.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The 10% Treat Rule for Chickens: How Many Treats to Feed (Without Ruining Their Diet)

The Complete List: Foods Chickens Can and Can't Eat (Safe & Toxic Guide)

How to Keep Chicken Water From Freezing in Winter (10 Fixes That Actually Work)