Why Are My Chicken Eggs Different Colors? (Blame Genetics, Not Diet)

By Peter Chan

Researched with AI help and checked against the sources listed below.

Illustration of white, brown and blue eggs for the guide: Why are my chicken eggs different colors?

Chicken eggs come in different colours because of the hen's breed and genes, not her diet. All eggs start out white, and some breeds add pigments as the shell forms. Shell colour does not change the egg's nutrition or, in practice, its taste.

This guide explains how shell colour is made, which breeds lay which colours, what feed can and cannot change, and some common myths.

Quick answer

  • Why colours differ: breed and genes. Pigments are added in the uterus (shell gland): protoporphyrin IX for brown, biliverdin for blue.
  • Diet: does not change shell colour, only yolk colour.
  • Rough guide: white earlobes often mean white eggs, but there are exceptions.
  • Paler brown eggs: normal as hens age; stress, some drugs and disease such as infectious bronchitis can also cause pale shells (UF IFAS; Merck).
  • Nutrition: shell colour does not affect nutritive value (USDA FSIS).

How shell colour is made

The shell forms in the hen's shell gland (uterus). The USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service (FSIS) notes that the egg stays there for about 21 hours, and that "depending on the hen breed, pigments may also be added to make the shell brown." University of Florida IFAS Extension puts it simply: "all eggs start out white," and colour comes from pigments deposited on them.

Research on eggshell colour names three main pigments: protoporphyrin IX, biliverdin and a zinc form of biliverdin. A 2019 study in Frontiers in Genetics explains that brown eggs come from protoporphyrin alone, while blue eggs contain biliverdin, often alongside protoporphyrin.

A 2013 study in PLOS Genetics sums up the chemistry: protoporphyrin IX, biliverdin and a zinc form of biliverdin are the main eggshell pigments, the uterus is where pigment is secreted onto the shell, and a blue egg is coloured mainly by biliverdin deposited on the shell.

Shell colourWhat causes it
WhiteNo added pigment
Brown (light to dark)Protoporphyrin pigment
BlueBiliverdin, linked to a dominant gene
Green, olive or other shadesFound in certain breeds and crosses, such as Easter Eggers

The blue egg gene

Blue shells come from genetics, not illness. eXtension explains that long ago a retrovirus inserted genetic material into the ancestors of blue-egg chickens, and that this DNA leads to blue shells. The chickens do not spread any virus; it is simply part of their genetic history. The Frontiers in Genetics study describes the blue-egg trait as autosomal dominant, meaning a hen needs only one copy of the gene to lay blue eggs.

Which breeds lay which colours

ColourExample breeds (from extension sources)
WhiteWhite Leghorn, Polish
BrownRhode Island Red, Plymouth Rock, Australorp, Orpington, Wyandotte, New Hampshire
Blue or greenAraucana
Light blue, light green or light pinkAmeraucana
Green, blue or light brownEaster Egger

eXtension gives a general pattern for commercial birds: chickens with white feathers and white earlobes lay white eggs, while chickens with red feathers and red earlobes lay brown eggs. It is a rule of thumb, not a guarantee. For more on choosing layers, see our guide to the best egg-laying breeds.

Washington State University's "Ask Dr. Universe" adds a useful caution: if a chicken's earlobes are white, her eggs tend to be white, but some chickens with red earlobes lay greenish or blue eggs, and scientists are not entirely sure why the link exists. Treat earlobes as a hint, not a rule.

Can diet change shell colour?

No. Shell colour depends on breed. What diet can change is the yolk colour. Oregon State University Extension notes, for example, that greens help keep yolks orange. See our guide on pale or orange yolks.

Diet does affect shell strength. A shortage of calcium can lead to thin or soft shells, but not a new colour.

Does colour affect nutrition or taste?

No. FSIS states: "Neither the color of the shell nor that of the yolk affects the egg's nutritive value." UF IFAS says there is no nutritional difference between colourful eggs and white eggs. eXtension notes that brown and white eggs "basically taste the same," though a hen's diet can affect flavour.

The protective coating

FSIS explains that the shell has a thin outer coating called the cuticle (often called the bloom). It helps block the shell's roughly 17,000 tiny pores, which helps keep the egg fresh and keep germs out. This coating can make a shell look slightly matte. Washing removes it, which is one reason FSIS does not recommend that consumers wash eggs.

Why a basket of eggs looks so varied

  • Different hens. In a mixed flock, each hen lays her own colour.
  • Shade varies within a breed. Two brown-egg hens of the same breed can lay different shades.
  • New layers. A pullet that has just started laying adds a new colour or shade to the mix.

Why brown eggs get paler

Many keepers notice their brown eggs fading. University of Florida IFAS Extension explains the common causes in a fact sheet on poor pigmentation of brown-shelled eggs:

CauseWhat the source saysWhat to do
AgeAs a brown-egg hen ages, there is a corresponding decrease in shell pigment intensity (UF IFAS)Normal; nothing needed
StressStressors that cause nervousness and fear can lead to pale shells (UF IFAS)Look for predators, crowding, loud noise or rough handling
Certain drugsA rapid decline in shell colour is common after hens take certain drugs, such as sulfonamides (UF IFAS)Ask your vet about side effects of any treatment
DiseaseIn infectious bronchitis, eggs are often misshapen, with thin, soft, wrinkled, rough or pale shells, and may have watery whites (Merck)If shells change suddenly with breathing signs or fewer eggs, call a vet

A gradual fade over a season or two is usually age. A sudden change across several hens, especially with other egg problems, deserves a closer look. See our guides to watery egg whites and soft-shelled eggs.

If one hen's eggs suddenly look very different and stay that way, or shells become thin or misshapen, think about her health, heat stress and diet.

Colour and freshness

Shell colour tells you nothing about how fresh an egg is. Use the egg float test or crack the egg into a bowl to check. Small red or brown spots inside the egg are a different matter; see blood spots and meat spots.

Frequently asked questions

Are brown eggs healthier than white eggs?

No. FSIS and UF IFAS both say shell colour does not affect nutrition.

Can I feed my hens something to make them lay blue eggs?

No. Blue shells come from a dominant gene. Only breeds that carry it lay blue eggs.

Why do some hens lay green eggs?

Green shells come from certain breeds and crosses. UF IFAS lists Easter Eggers as laying green, blue or light brown eggs.

Does a rooster change egg colour?

No. The hen's own genes decide her egg colour. A rooster only affects the genes of any chicks she hatches.

Why are my brown eggs getting lighter?

Usually age: UF IFAS says pigment intensity falls as brown-egg hens get older. Stress, some medicines and disease can also cause pale shells.

Can I tell egg colour from a hen's earlobes?

Often, but not always. White earlobes tend to go with white eggs, yet some red-eared hens lay blue or green eggs.

The bottom line

Egg colour is set by breed and genes. Brown shells contain protoporphyrin, blue shells contain biliverdin, and white shells have no added pigment. Diet changes the yolk, not the shell colour, and colour has no effect on nutrition. A mixed basket of colours is simply a sign of a mixed flock.

What egg colours do you collect from your flock? Tell us in the comments.

Like this guide? Follow CluckSmart on Pinterest for more simple, sourced chicken care guides and checklists.

Sources / Further reading

CluckSmart is an educational resource, not veterinary advice. If a bird is ill or injured, contact a licensed vet.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The 10% Treat Rule for Chickens: How Many Treats to Feed (Without Ruining Their Diet)

The Complete List: Foods Chickens Can and Can't Eat (Safe & Toxic Guide)

How to Keep Chicken Water From Freezing in Winter (10 Fixes That Actually Work)