Soft-Shell and Shell-less Eggs in Chickens: Why It Happens and How to Fix It Fast (Calcium, Age and Disease)
By Peter Chan
Researched with AI help and checked against the sources listed below.
An occasional soft-shelled or shell-less egg is usually nothing to worry about, especially from a hen that has just started laying. If soft eggs keep appearing, or several hens lay them, check the feed and calcium first, then look at heat, stress and the flock's health, because some viral diseases also cause soft shells.
- One odd egg: usually harmless, common in new layers.
- Repeated soft eggs: feed a complete layer feed (3 to 4% calcium), cut back treats, and offer oyster shell in a separate dish. Dried, crushed eggshells are another option (see eggshells vs oyster shell).
- Also check: heat, recent scares, hen age, and vitamin D in the diet.
- Call a vet if: soft eggs come with coughing, sneezing, a sharp drop in laying, a hen straining, or sudden deaths.
This guide explains how an eggshell is made, the common causes of soft and missing shells, a simple checklist, and when to call a vet.
How a hen makes an eggshell
Poultry Extension explains that it takes about 25 to 26 hours to form an egg, and that the egg stays in the shell gland (uterus) for 20 or more hours while the shell is added. The shell is made largely of calcium carbonate. The hen gets this calcium partly from her feed and partly from her own bones: bone calcium supplies about 47% of the calcium needed for a shell. The same page notes that more shell-less eggs can point to a shortage of calcium, phosphorus or vitamin D.
So anything that disrupts this process, such as too little calcium in the diet, too little vitamin D, stress, heat or illness, can lead to thin, soft or missing shells.
What you might find in the nest
| What you see | What it usually means |
|---|---|
| Shell-less egg: only the membrane, like a soft water balloon | The shell was never added. Often a new layer or a stress event; if frequent, check diet and health |
| Soft or rubbery shell | The shell started but did not harden properly: check calcium, vitamin D and feed |
| Thin shells that crack easily | Often diet, heat or an older hen laying larger eggs |
| Wrinkled or ridged shells, with fewer eggs or breathing signs | Can point to infectious bronchitis or another viral disease; talk to a vet |
Common causes
1. Not enough calcium in the diet
This is the most common cause in backyard flocks. Oregon State University Extension explains that layer feed contains extra calcium (3 to 4%) for strong shells, and that hens fed all-purpose feed will generally not get enough calcium for proper shells. Alabama Cooperative Extension also lists calcium at 3 to 4% of a layer diet. Too many treats, scratch grains or kitchen scraps dilute the layer feed and lower the calcium a hen actually eats.
2. No oyster shell on offer
Oregon State suggests giving laying hens ground oyster shell in a separate feeder so they can take it as they need it, and says free-choice oyster shell is required for birds on all-purpose feed. Alabama Cooperative Extension notes oyster shell is mostly calcium carbonate (around 95%). If hens are on a good complete layer feed, Alabama says extra oyster shell is probably unnecessary, but it is inexpensive and will not cause harm. Oyster shell is not a substitute for grit; see our guide to grit vs oyster shell.
3. Not enough vitamin D
The Merck Veterinary Manual lists poor eggshell quality among the signs of vitamin D shortage in laying hens. It says hens fed a diet short of vitamin D3 lose egg production within 2 to 3 weeks, and that shell quality gets worse almost at once. Complete layer feeds are formulated to supply the vitamins hens need, which is another reason to keep them as the main part of the diet.
4. A young hen just starting to lay
The first eggs from a new layer are often odd: small, soft or missing a shell. This usually settles within a few weeks. Oregon State advises starting layer feed at about 18 to 20 weeks of age or when the first egg appears, whichever comes first. See when chickens start laying for more.
5. An older hen laying bigger eggs
Shell problems also show up at the other end of a hen's laying life. University of Florida IFAS Extension explains that as a hen ages and her eggs get bigger, a similar amount of calcium has to be spread over a larger surface, and that large eggs usually break more easily than small ones. Alabama Extension adds that a hen can only put a certain amount of calcium into her shell, so extra calcium beyond her needs has only marginal effects on shell thickness. In other words, an older hen's thinner shells are partly normal and cannot always be fixed with more calcium.
6. Stress and disturbance
The Merck Veterinary Manual notes that abnormal eggs are much more common in hens under stressful management or rough handling. A night-time scare from a predator, a storm, moving birds or adding new ones can all lead to a soft egg or two. Quiet, secure nights help.
7. Hot weather
UF/IFAS Extension lists hens not eating enough feed as one of the reasons shell quality is poorer in hot weather, and notes that shell quality is less of a problem in cooler conditions. Less feed means less calcium. Keep birds cool and keep fresh water available; our guide to keeping chickens cool in summer covers what to do.
8. Disease
Merck notes that a clear increase in soft-shelled eggs is common with viral diseases including infectious bronchitis, egg drop syndrome, Newcastle disease, avian pneumovirus and avian influenza. Watch for other signs: coughing, sneezing or rattling, swollen faces, a sharp drop in laying, or sudden deaths. If you see these, contact a vet. Sudden deaths should be reported to a vet or state animal health officials straight away.
A note on calcium and phosphorus
More calcium is not always better. Alabama Cooperative Extension gives the calcium-to-phosphorus ratio for laying hens as about 4:1, possibly as high as 7:1, compared with a 2:1 rule of thumb for most animals. A complete layer feed is formulated to get this balance right, which is why it should make up most of the diet.
When to watch, and when to call a vet
| Situation | What to do |
|---|---|
| One soft egg from a healthy, active hen | Watch. Check feed and oyster shell. |
| Soft eggs for a week or more from one hen | Review diet and treats, offer oyster shell, check for stress or heat. |
| Several hens laying soft or wrinkled eggs | Check the feed bag and storage. If birds also cough, sneeze or lay far fewer eggs, call a vet. |
| A hen straining, sitting hunched or tail pumping | Call a vet. See our guide to an egg bound chicken. |
| Sudden deaths in the flock | Call a vet or state animal health officials straight away. |
Quick soft-egg checklist
- Is the main feed a complete layer feed (not all-purpose or grower)?
- Is the feed fresh? Oregon State says to store feed for a maximum of two months in a cool, dry, closed container.
- Are treats and scratch kept small? Oregon State suggests only what hens can eat in about 20 minutes.
- Is oyster shell available in a separate dish?
- Has there been heat, a scare or a change in the flock this week?
- Is the hen young and new to laying, or older and laying large eggs?
- Are any birds sick, coughing or laying far fewer eggs? If yes, call a vet.
Frequently asked questions
Are soft-shelled eggs safe to eat?
The USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service warns that bacteria can enter eggs through cracks in the shell, and advises against buying cracked eggs. A soft or broken shell gives the egg the same weak protection. Do not store or sell these eggs. If you choose to use one, use it straight away and cook it until the yolk and white are firm; if in doubt, throw it out. Our guide to frozen or cracked eggs covers more egg-safety questions.
My hen lays shell-less eggs but seems healthy. Why?
If she is young, it is often part of starting to lay. Otherwise check her feed and calcium, offer oyster shell, and think about recent stress or heat. If it continues or other hens are affected, talk to a vet.
Can I just add more calcium?
Offer oyster shell free-choice and feed a complete layer feed. Alabama Extension notes that extra calcium has only marginal effects once a hen's needs are met, so more is not always better.
Do older hens lay thinner shells?
Often, yes. UF/IFAS explains that older hens lay bigger eggs with the same amount of calcium spread over a larger shell, so cracks become more common.
Should growing pullets eat layer feed?
Not before they are close to laying. Oregon State advises switching at about 18 to 20 weeks or at the first egg, whichever comes first.
The bottom line
A single soft egg is rarely a problem. Repeated soft or shell-less eggs usually mean the diet needs fixing: a complete layer feed, fewer treats, and oyster shell on the side. Reduce stress, keep birds cool in summer, expect a few thinner shells from older hens, and call a vet if soft eggs come with sick birds, straining or a sharp drop in laying.
CluckSmart is an educational resource, not veterinary advice. If a bird is ill or injured, contact a licensed vet.
Have you found soft-shell or shell-less eggs? What do you think caused them? Tell us in the comments.
Like this guide? Follow CluckSmart on Pinterest for more simple, sourced chicken care guides and checklists.
Sources / Further reading
- Oregon State University Extension: How to Feed Your Laying Hens (PNW 477) (layer feed calcium, oyster shell, feed storage)
- Alabama Cooperative Extension System: Feeding the Laying Hen (calcium levels, calcium-to-phosphorus ratio, oyster shell)
- Poultry Extension: Avian Reproductive System, Female (how and how long the shell is formed)
- Merck Veterinary Manual: Defective or Abnormal Eggs in Poultry (stress and viral diseases)
- Merck Veterinary Manual: Vitamin Deficiencies in Poultry (vitamin D3 and shell quality)
- University of Florida IFAS Extension: Concepts of Eggshell Quality (hen age, hot weather)
- USDA FSIS: Shell Eggs from Farm to Table (cracks and bacteria, cooking eggs)

Comments
Post a Comment